Bonjour, from what was, for a long time, the home of movers and shakers in the auction market: Geneva, Switzerland. Actually, I come to you from the train as I head up to Zürich and onward, but you’re not here for a travel report. In a way, though, Geneva’s results this week—or rather, how the auction houses came into the week and positioned themselves—show some geographic realignment.
Phillips continues to set records with another “white glove” sale (100% of lots sold) that was the first live watch auction to break $100 million. With $112.3 million worth of watches sold and 17 lots over CHF 1 million—Patek Philippe, Rolex, Cartier, F.P. Journe, Harry Winston, Voutilainen, and Philippe Dufour—Phillips seems to largely dominate the energy in Geneva these days. It’s spectacle sometimes, just as much as collecting, which we’ll get to in a moment.
Instead of trying to fight it out, it seems Sotheby’s (and, to a lesser extent, Christie’s) are slightly redirecting effort to New York, which is increasingly becoming a sale location that mirrors the market’s overall importance. That being said, Christie’s also set a record for their auction house with a white-glove sale in Geneva and a $58 million total, 221% of what they made last year. Hong Kong is hard for me to feel out, and with a ton of lots, it often feels like a clearinghouse. Sometimes it’s hard to tell if HK and the Chinese market are buying voraciously or offloading expeditiously. Regardless, that doesn’t mean there wasn’t news at other auction houses this weekend. Here are three (big, long) takeaways.
Table of Contents
1. Big Results But Big Worries For The F.P. Journe Market
We came into the auction season with some drama and confusion around F.P. Journe. The highly-touted 022/99R was originally framed by Phillips as the first Pre-Production Résonance ever sold. This turned out, according to François-Paul Journe himself, not to be the case, and he’s the last word on these things. Multiple sources tell me that the reason Phillips had to walk back these claims was due to some cat-and-mouse gamesmanship by François-Paul Journe to only share what was expedient, when it was expedient.
Remember when Journe said he wouldn’t service the Breguet Sympathique clock that was up for sale, then proceeded to buy it? One take is that it’s prerogative—it’s his knowledge and his clients, and not every brand shares everything anyway. More than one person told me that they think the owner truly believed that it was the first delivered and didn’t know it wasn’t. Heck, a lot of collectors did until Journe said otherwise.

Another view is that, numbered 022, it still is the earliest number pre-Souscription made, which is a big deal. It seems as though 022/99R was interesting enough that Shawn Mehta, head of F.P. Journe’s boutique in London and one of the closest people to Journe himself, was the winning bidder at CHF 4.93 million. Many people (myself included) considered that the purchase could be for Journe, with the brand’s museum opening next year, but that might be odd, as François-Paul Journe already owns the first pre-Souscription example, 021/99R (and the prototype). After this article was published, Mehta reached out to confirm that in fact 022/99R was purchased for a “dear friend” and not Montres Journe, and that Mr. Journe does all the acquisitions himself, which probably keeps things a lot clearer to the competition.
Last December, I stood next to the seller of the record-breaking Journe Souscription Resonance the day after the lot closed for $13.9m and became the fifth most expensive wristwatch ever sold when it hammered at Phillips New York. While happy with the result, he said that he expected the record wouldn’t last long, knowing that this watch was going to come to market. I would say there was some momentum going into the sale that Journe quickly quashed, and the result was lower than expected months ago. But it’s still rarefied air for a watch sale.

Even if there was some gamesmanship, it makes sense on a few levels, beyond just getting a better price. Journe has become the new “access flex” among CEOs, according to a number of dealers, breaking containment of the normal watch nerd crowd. Sources within the brand find the current demand unsustainable and actually want a cool-down. Could that have been Journe’s motivation all along? But that, then, becomes even more curious when F.P. Journe’s Patrimony (secondary market sales) service announced on Monday that they will be selling 024/99R, another Pre-Souscription watch from the same year. Was that the actual first watch delivered? They said they won’t be commenting on that. But as of writing, the overlay on the website says it’s withdrawn from sale.

That doesn’t mean there weren’t some tremendous results otherwise. One of the biggest bits of entertainment came early on Phillips first day, when the likely unique Regency-dial Résonance came up as lot 7. As specialists on the phone shouted, starting around CHF 1 million, trying to get their clients’ bids in at CHF 200,000 increments, Aurel Bacs asked for some quiet as he couldn’t hear a bid in the back of the room. It was Shawn Mehta, “throwing the hammer” early at CHF 5 million against a standing 2.6 million bid. Nearly the entire room collectively turned to look.
It went to 5.2, then 5.4, then Mehta went to 6. Things slowed down to 6.2, and Mehta tried to throw the hammer once again to 7 million to signal deep pockets. Instead, Alex Ghotbi’s phone bidder went to 7.1 million, testing Mehta’s true limit, which turned out to be 7 flat. Ghotbi’s client got the watch for CHF 7.1 million, which resulted in an all-in price of $10.5 million in US Dollars.

Another outstanding result came later, though I wasn’t there, when a Vagabondage III (number 1 of 10 in platinum with diamonds) sold for CHF 5,057,000 or $6.15 million. It was a shocking result, most of all to a dealer in the room who sold one in January for $1.2 million (up from an initial ask of $800,000 in late November).

Similarly, on Monday, a specialist from Christie’s represented a bidder who paid CHF 4,756,200 in total for a set of three Vagabondage in rose gold. The first lot was won with a “cut bid” at a somewhat rude level, increasing by CHF 15,000 when the interval was going at 50,000 increments already past CHF 1.5m. But hey, the auctioneer accepted it and it got the win. The underbidder who lost the first watch made the competition pay big, driving up the price on the others. Even halfway through the second lot, I leaned forward to Andy Hoffman and said: “This guy is going to get screwed on the box.” That final, somewhat minor, lot started with the underbidder offering CHF 5,000, bumped by the winner of the watches to 20,000, then immediately to 100,000 by the previous underbidder again, and increased again to nearly CHF 200,000 to secure the box for the now-owner of the watches. It’s one of the first times I recall a whole set going to a single owner, so in that way it was a treat.

Other houses didn’t put as many eggs in the Journe basket, but Sotheby’s and Christie’s both had a few from the brand sell over CHF 1 million. So, all sunshine and record-setting roses for Journe? Not according to dealers, collectors, and scholars. I spoke to a number of people on background, who wanted to protect their relationship with the brand, who see a slowdown, plateau, or even signs of distress coming for the secondary market. One longtime scholar and collector told me that they worried that 24 lots in Phillips New York (12% of the sale) could result in a pretty depressed market if they don’t maintain some success, but that we might be slowing to a plateau (or worse).
One dealer, who sells a lot of high-end Journe, said that a lot of these watches are coming from early collectors trying to capitalize on the moment, but that the market is saturated, especially in the mid-range. “The same pieces that are selling for massive prices at auction, the under buyers won’t buy other examples privately for 30% off or less,” they told me. Dealers are sitting on stock, they said, and the consensus is that people setting record-breaking prices better be buying to keep or okay with being underwater. And yet, maybe that will be healthier for the market—a reset button to get things back to reasonable prices.
2. Patek Philippe Results Had Some Highs And A Few Surprising Mids
Okay, that was a lot of digital ink spilled on F.P. Journe, so I’ll try to keep this shorter. It’s not true that Patek is particularly soft across the board or has bargain-basement prices anywhere. It continues to be a blue-chip brand for collectors, with blue-chip results to match.

Take, for instance, the steel ref. 1436 split-second chronograph. This will likely be the last time you’ll get a chance to buy this watch for a long time, with the other correct example in a royal collection, and bidders certainly showed up. The final result was $7.6 million all-in, which blows the previous record for the reference (the same watch in 2015 at $3.29 million) out of the water by more than double. The yellow gold Tiffany-signed example, however, went for CHF 584,200, which was on the low end of the estimate range (albeit a solid result for the reference).

A number of Calatravas did quite well, including a solid selection at Phillips. A ref. 570 steel “Breguet” dial went for CHF 1.1 million and change, the two-tone Eberhard-signed 570 was at CHF 508,000, and this 565 at Sotheby’s did quite well. People standing next to me at Phillips were actually talking about how impressed they were with the result of the 2497 “Gumbiner,” which, at $864,000 or so, was not a record but a solid result for a non-1518 or 2499 in yellow gold. The 3424 “Gilbert Albert” went for CHF 700,000+, but the estimate was ridiculously low. Oh, and a Sky Moon Tourbillon ref. 5002 was nearly CHF 3 million at Sotheby’s. And that’s not even people’s favorite Sky Moon Tourbillon.

Then there was the Khanjar-signed Nautilus ref. 3700 in yellow gold (with box) at Christie’s, which barely beat out a white gold version from Monaco Legend Group a few years ago, this time landing just over CHF 1 million all-in. It was a good result, but not incredibly amazing. Nor were the two early 5004s at Phillips, which are good scholarship pieces with various transitional configurations that felt a bit soft to me. The reference was hot last year, but seems to have cooled off a bit. And okay, fair point, those were still huge results. But maybe the fact that there are a lot of variants of 5004s has slowed some people’s rolls.

But the problem with a saturated market is that not everything can grow. Some mid-to-late-era perpetual calendars had what felt like middling results. Later-era Lemania watches like 5970/5971 stuff felt like they got overshadowed (alongside the 5004s). This 5216 feels like a steal at this price, for how good this watch and movement is. Nautilus have cooled off (though still way too high), and even some vintage pieces like 1463s (at all auction houses) didn’t show growth. Which is fine. We need a healthy collecting space, not just a booming market, and if you’re lucky enough to be able to pick up a 5970 or 5004, now might be a good time.
3. Sylvain Pinaud Joins The Million-Dollar Club, As Indies and Revival-Period Watches Show Strength
The relative newcomer (despite his 48 years of age), Sylvain Pinaud has joined a prestigious club of living watchmakers with million-dollar results to his name. The climb happened in quick succession, with a Marteau & Co. auction in October that had a unique Origine fetch CHF 528,000, then Phillips over the weekend got $743,590 all-in for Origine Nº2 in steel. But we were in the room as another unique piece hammered on Monday at Christie’s for CHF 790,000, with an all-in price of CHF 1,011,200 or $1.23 million. With that, he joins the likes of F.P. Journe, Roger Smith, Rexhep Rexhepi, Kari Voutilainen, and Philippe Dufour among million-dollar makers.

And speaking of Philippe Dufour, his work achieved two outstanding results this weekend. Marteau & Co went first and set a record for the model with a unique Simplicity at CHF 2 million and change. That’s about double the first time it was sold, only a few years ago. At that time, it was offered for charity, and without any extra charity incentive this time, it still made a huge result. Phillips then offered a more standard early Simplicity, not unique, and still got just shy of CHF 2 million.

That’s not to say all modern independents were being bought up at a fast clip. Things like certain Grönefeld and MB&Fs had sluggish bidding on occasion, while others, like this recent LM Split Escapement with engraved dial, did okay, going for about 20% over retail. I take this as meaning that people are separating simpler, more artisanal watchmaking from complex watchmaking where they don’t see or feel the hands-on approach of the makers as much (regardless of how true that is).

Kari Voutilainen’s work continued to do remarkably well over the weekend. People are privately just assuming that—with a lot of interest and a waitlist that now stretches past a decade—his work will hover around a million dollars for a while. The results were led by a unique Vignt-8 Inverse for CHF 1,524,000 at Phillips, plus another CHF 960,000 for a watch at Christie’s, while the two unique “Jumbo” watches achieved CHF 720,000 at Marteau and CHF 635,000 at Phillips. And while it wasn’t a record, the George Daniels Millennium (made by Roger Smith under Daniels’ instruction) got a very impressive CHF 1.5 million result at Sotheby’s.

I lump these watchmakers into a legacy that dates back to a revival period of people like Christian Klings, Derek Pratt, and people like Richard Miklosch, whose incredible tourbillon pocket watch sold for CHF 762,000 to one of the market’s most scholarly collectors, who got a relative deal shortly after another watch by “the watchmakers’ watchmaker” sold at Corterie recently for over $1 million. On that “revival period” note, Urban Jürgensen felt pretty strong, and Sotheby’s sold a tonal pink Reference 2 for over $400,000.

I count this as part of the period where commercial revival in the post-Quartz-Crisis period was at its height, so a final shout-out has to go to Sotheby’s for presenting the first-ever 3970, with movement serial 875’000, which achieved a record price of just over CHF 2 million. The reference is on the rise, but this felt like a great result for a truly historically important but otherwise on-its-face unremarkable-looking watch. This kind of difference between importance and eye-catching hype used to mean more, and it seems like it might be coming back around.
Bonus Round:

There were three watches that felt surprisingly low for me that I wanted to mention. If you got the Leonidas split-second or Rolex 5512 gilt dial full set at Antiquorum, or the Rolex 6032 at Sotheby’s, congrats. I think you got a great deal on watches, with results that left me confused. Maybe someone knows something I don’t. In fact, a lot of people know something I don’t. But I thought they’d all go for much higher.
Oh, and if you were watching football (or social media, I guess) this weekend, you might have seen that Tom Brady has his unique Audemars Piguet Royal Oak Flying Tourbillon (the one with his name in gems on the dial) back on his wrist. He flexed that on his Instagram story, which is a surprise because he sold it at a Sotheby’s auction in 2024 for $720,000. Then it came up for sale again at Sotheby’s Hong Kong, where it sold for $621,000, so if he bought it back then, he actually made a little money. Brady wore the watch while covering Jordan Love, Christian Watson, Matthew Golden, and my Green Bay Packers as they trounced the New England Patriots. Way to go, boys. Go Pack Go!
Editor’s note: This story was updated after confirmation was shared that Montres Journe did not buy any watches for the brand this weekend.



